Postby KyleR » September 30th, 2022, 10:39 am
I got quotes through Markel (via USAA), State Farm, a private broker and finally through nboat.com. We also were moving up from a 22ft center console (the largest boat we previously owned) to the Carver 396 so it was a pretty big jump. This is how things came back for us:
Markel - wouldn't insure us because the marina the boat was at was greater than 2 hours from our home. If we wanted to move it to a closer marina they would provide coverage but required 8 hours of training.
State Farm - provided coverage with almost no stipulations (not even a survey) but would only do "actual cash value" and not "agreed value" which we did not like. Also had to be north of Florida during hurricane season.
Private broker - rates were about $1000 higher than the other three quotes and the underwriter wanted 50 hours of training!!! Yes - FIFTY HOURS!!!
nboat.com - This ended up being written through Progressive insurance and had no geographical stipulations or training requirements.
Markel, State Farm and nboat.com all had premiums of approximately 2% of the cost of the boat and the private broker rate was almost 3% of the cost of the boat.
In the end we went with the Progressive policy through nboat.com due to the comparable rates, no geographical restrictions and no training requirements. They did want an out-of-water survey but we were already planning that for our peace-of-mind so that wasn't really an issue.
Even though it wasn't required, we did end up doing some training through the selling agent.
Hope that helps!
Kyle
MV Verity
2002 Carver 396
Twin Cummins 6BTA 370HP